Categories
Blog Tour Book launch book promo Book review Book reviews

#Bookreview and #Blogtour THE OTHER EINSTEIN by Marie Benedict @sourcebooks Re-evaluations and fictionalised history.

Hi all:

As you know I read a lot and I share reviews. On this occasion, when I saw this book on offer on NetGalley I thought it looked very intriguing, and when a member of the publicity team for the novel got in touch and asked if I’d like to take part in the tour I agreed. At that point I hadn’t read the novel yet, and I worried it might take me some time to get to it, so I booked it for later in November. That has meant that the author was busy with her own live tour and could not provide an original feature for it, but I include the press release, my own review for you and also, if you’re quick, a promotion that will allow you to get it at a special price.

The Other Einstein by Marie Benedict
The Other Einstein by Marie Benedict

The Other Einstein by Marie Benedict

October 18, 2016; Hardcover, ISBN 9781492637257 

Book Info:

Title: The Other Einstein

Author: Marie Benedict

Release Date: October 18, 2016

Publisher: Sourcebooks Landmark

Praise for The Other Einstein

October 2016 Indie Next and LibraryReads Pick!

PopSugar’s “25 Books You’re Going to Curl Up with this Fall”

“The Other Einstein takes you into Mileva’s heart, mind, and study as she tries to forge a place for herself in a scientific world dominated by men.”– Bustle

“…an ENGAGING and THOUGHT PROVOKING fictional telling of the poignant story of an overshadowed woman scientist.”– Booklist

“…INTIMATE and IMMERSIVE historical novel….

Prepare to be moved by this provocative history of a woman whose experiences will resonate with today’s readers.”– Library Journal, Editors’ Fall Picks

“Many will enjoy Benedict’s feminist views and be fascinated by the life of an almost unknown woman.”– RT Book Reviews, 4 Stars

“Benedict’s debut novel carefully traces Mileva’s life—from studious schoolgirl to bereaved mother—with attention paid to the conflicts between personal goals and social conventions. An intriguing… reimagining of one of the strongest intellectual partnerships of the 19th century.” Kirkus

“In her compelling novel… Benedict makes a strong case that the brilliant woman behind [Albert Einstein] was integral to his success, and creates a rich historical portrait in the process.” Publishers Weekly

Summary:

A vivid and mesmerizing novel about the extraordinary woman who married and worked with one of the greatest scientists in history. 

What secrets may have lurked in the shadows of Albert Einstein’s fame? His first wife, Mileva “Mitza” Maric_, was more than the devoted mother of their three children—she was also a brilliant physicist in her own right, and her contributions to the special theory of relativity have been hotly debated for more than a century.

But as Albert’s fame grows, so too does Mileva’s worry that her light will be lost in her husband’s shadow forever. A literary historical in the tradition of The Paris Wife and Mrs. PoeThe Other Einstein reveals a complicated partnership that is as fascinating as it is troubling.

Goodreads Link:  http://ow.ly/y83l305MKdq

Buy Links:

Amazon: http://ow.ly/MvWy305MKr5

Barnes & Noble: http://ow.ly/Ya8l305MKC6

IndieBound: http://ow.ly/57fK305MKSh

 

Author Marie Benedict
Author Marie Benedict

About the Author:

Marie Benedict is a lawyer with more than ten years’ experience as a litigator at two of the country’s premier law firms and for Fortune 500 companies. She is a magna cum laude graduate of Boston College with a focus in history and art history and a cum laude graduate of the Boston University School of Law. She lives in Pittsburgh with her family.

Social Media Links:

Author Website: http://www.authormariebenedict.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/authormariebenedict/#

Here, my review:

Thanks to NetGalley and to Sourcebooks Landmark for offering me an ARC copy of the book. I voluntarily decided to review it.

We’ve all heard the saying: ‘Behind every great man there’s a great woman’ in its many different versions. It’s true that for centuries men (or many men of the wealthy classes with access to education) could dedicate themselves to artistic, scientific or business pursuits because the everyday things were taken care of by their wives or other women in their lives (mothers, relatives, partners…) As Virginia Wolf wrote in ‘A Room of One’s Own’ women had a harder time of it, as they were expected to take care of the house, family, and ensure that their husbands came back to a place where they would be looked after and tended too. Unless women were independently wealthy and could count on the support (financial, emotional and practical) of the men in their lives, it was very hard, if not impossible, to pursue a career in the arts or the sciences.

Mary Benedict’s book explores the life of Mitza Maric, who would later become Einstein’s first wife, from the time of her arrival in Zurich (as one of only a few female students at the university) to the time when she separates from her husband. Maric is an intriguing figure (and I must admit I hadn’t read anything about her before) and an inspiring one, as she had to go against the odds (being a woman at a time were very few women could study at university, suffering from hip dysplasia, that left her with a limp and difficulty in undertaking certain physical tasks) and managed to study and be respected for her knowledge of Physics and Maths.

The book is written in the first person, and we get a close look at Maric´s thoughts, emotions and doubts. The early part of the book is a very good read, with descriptions of the social mores of the era, Mitza’s family, the development of her friendship with the other female students at the lodgings, the intellectual atmosphere and café society of that historical period, and of course, Mr Einstein, whom he meets at University. Mitza believed (like her parents) that due to her physical disability she would never marry, and lived resigned to the idea, having decided to dedicate her life to her research, studies and the academic life she craved. And then… Einstein arrives.

The Einstein depicted by the book is a bit of a Jekyll and Hyde character. He’s friendly, humorous and charming, and also, of course, a brilliant scientist, but can be selfish, egotistical and cares nothing for anybody who is not himself. We see more of the first Einstein at the beginning of the relationship, through their interaction, walks, scientific discussions… Einstein opens the world for Mitza, and if she had been enjoying the company of the other girls, she later neglects them for the world of scientific discussion among men, where she gains entry thanks to Einstein.

When, after much hesitation, Mitza decides to visit Einstein and spend a few days with him in Lake Como, the two of them alone, the book becomes more melodramatic and things start going very wrong. Mitza gets pregnant, Einstein keeps making excuses not to get married yet, and resentment sets in. If I mentioned that Einstein is a Jekyll and Hyde character, Mitza, who was always shy but determined and stubborn, also changes; she becomes sad, hesitant, and she seems unable to follow her own path. In the book, there is much internal discussion and debate, as on the one hand she does not like Einstein’s behaviour, but on the other, she tries to see things from her mother’s point of view and do what’s right for the child.

As some reviewers have noted (and the writer acknowledges in her notes at the back of the book), it’s a fact that they had a daughter out of wedlock, but it’s not clear what happened to her, and that makes the later part of the book, at least for me, stand on shakier grounds. That is always a difficulty with historical fiction, whereby to flesh out the story authors must make decisions, interpreting events and sometimes filling in gaps. In some cases, this is more successful than others, and it might also depend on the reader and their ability to suspend disbelief.

The author comes up with an explanation for the possible origin of the theory of relativity, closely linked to Mitza’s faith (and I know there have been debates as to how much Einstein’s wife contributed to it, and she definitely did contribute, although most likely not as much as is suggested in the book) that hinges around a dramatic event affecting their daughter, the problem being (from a historical point of view) that there’s no evidence it ever took place. That event, as depicted in the text, has a major impact in later parts of the novel and seems to underline all of the later difficulties the couple has, although Einstein’s behaviour, his reluctance to include his wife’s name in any of the articles or patents, the time he spends away, and his infidelities don’t help.

I found it difficult to reconcile the woman of the beginning of the book with the beaten down character of the later part of the book, although there are some brief flashes of her former self, like when she converses with Marie Curie. Although there is much self-justification for her continuing to live with Einstein given the circumstances (she is doing it for the children, she still hopes he will seek her ideas and collaboration and they’ll end up working together), one wonders how the strong and determined woman of the beginning can end up tolerating such a frustrating life (especially once Albert becomes well known and their financial difficulties end). There is also no evidence that she sought to rekindle her career once she was no longer with Einstein, and one can’t help but wonder if perhaps their relationship, at least early on, was also a source of inspiration for her too.

I enjoyed getting to know a bit more about Mitza Maric, and in particular about the era and the difficulties women had to face then, although I would have preferred to be more aware of where the facts ended and author creativity started whilst reading the book, as I was never sure if some of the inconsistencies within the characters were due to their own experiences and circumstances, or to the reimagining of some parts of the story, that perhaps ends up transforming it into a more typical narrative of the woman whose ambitions and future die due to marriage, children and a less than enlightened husband. (It reminded me at times of Revolution Road, although in this instance both of the characters are talented, whilst there…) The author provides sources for further reading and research at the end that will prove invaluable to those interested in digging further.

In sum this book highlights the figure of a woman worth knowing better; it can work as the starting point for further research and fascinating discussions, and it is eminently readable. People looking for specific scientific information or accurate personal facts might need to consult other books as this is definitely a fictionalisation.

Here, the book is on special promotion until the 26th in Goodreads, so you’re in time if you’re quick!

the-othereinsteingoodreadspromo

Here is the link.

Thanks so much to NetGalley, Sourcebooks Landmark and to the author for her novel, thanks to all of you for reading, and if you’ve enjoyed it, like, share, comment and CLICK!

By OlgaNunez

I was born in Barcelona and after living in the UK for many years have now returned home. I teach English, volunteer at Sants 3 Ràdio, a local radio station, I'm a writer, translator (English-Spanish and vice-versa) and I'm a medical doctor and worked in Forensic Psychiatry many years. I also have a BA and a PhD in American Literature and Film, and a Masters in Criminology. I've always loved books and apart from writing them I review them often.
I write a bit of everything, check my books for more information and my about page for links.
My blog is bilingual, English and Spanish.

29 replies on “#Bookreview and #Blogtour THE OTHER EINSTEIN by Marie Benedict @sourcebooks Re-evaluations and fictionalised history.”

Albert Einstein is such a rich subject for the imagination. There are such great stories about him and about Mark Twain in particular. It must be fun to write them. Thanks for another mindful review, Olga. Have a wonderful weekend. Huge hugs.

Thanks, Teagan. Yes, he’s one of those bigger than life characters that fire up people’s imagination, no matter what their walk of life might be. I agree Mark Twain is another one. Perhaps it’s the crazy looking white hair… I hope you last NaNoWriMo weekend allows you to catch up on a lot of writing. (And may Mark Twain inspire you. With your choice of story I’m sure he’s looking over your shoulder ;))

You do have some of the best reviews Olga. Another fascinating read to bookmark. I may have to stay away from here as your reviews are bad for my reader’s wasitline, LOL. 🙂

Thanks, Erika. Being an author myself, and an avid reader, I know how important reviews are, and I’m pleased if I can bring any books I’ve enjoyed to the attention of readers. And of course, books that are not exactly what I like deserve readers too, so I try and describe the book to help others with different tastes to mine. My schedule these days revolves around computer time and reading mostly (and reading might mean reading in small chunks and use the word to speech facility when I’m doing chores or things that I can do and pay attention to what I’m listening to at the same time). I don’t know how you can fit in so many posts even when you’re busy, Erika! Have a lovely weekend.

Haha…. I think we all have our ‘secrets’ or ways adjusted to our personal circumstances in order to put as much within 24 hours as we love to do About 4 weeks ago I started scheduling all my posts for that following period until Dec 5 (including Twitter and Facebook that were about 80 posts). So it was simply a matter of organizing That’s why I can make it since I am mostly only around for the comments these days have a lovely weekend, Olga

No matter how we do it, you still had to dedicate them time when you programmed them. (I also programme my posts, usually a week in advance, unless I’m posting somebody else’s content and then it depends on when I get it, and I have the posts linked everywhere, but I share in Triberr and you’re expected to share other people’s posts so they share yours…)

That is actually true… lol. Whenever, the posts need time to be written. Since I am working my second job I am dedicating the weekends to writing and scheduling my posts for the week. I am happy about that scheduling option. That way we are free for unexpected or sadditional post

Yes, it’s true. I also find it helps to know that if something comes up at least you have some room to manoeuvre. I hope you have a great weekend.

Good morning Olga…Excellent review on a book that I feel sure I will enjoy. It’s a subject I know quite a bit about myself….the struggle of women in what is a still a man’s world in many ways. Over my lifetime, there have been huge improvements, but we still have a long way to go. I digress:) Thank you…and hope you enjoy a lovely weekend….filled with magic. Janet. x

Thanks, Janet. When I read about the book I knew I had to read it. It’s a subject that I’m always drawn to, one that can be sad at times (yes, we’ve come a long way but I agree there’s a long way to go yet), but joyful at others, as when I discover another woman hidden from history but who fought the good fight and should be remembered. Have a lovely weekend too. 🙂

I enjoyed your review, Olga, and am fascinated with this subject. <3 🙂
I read another review which chopped and diced the writing of this story. We tend to forget women 'back then' didn't have the wiggle room we do today. Also, if Einstein did mistreat, 'break' his wife's spirit– who was shy, though she could be stubborn–I'm in her corner. She may have become demoralized after his treatment and given up on herself in the day's man's world. Imagining she would never marry because of her dysplasia and then being pursued by this fellow student must have given her hope, only to end up disappointed. Just my thinking.

Thanks, Tess. The story as it’s told and during the period it covers makes sense (indeed, the character of the book overhears her parents saying she has no chance to get married due to her physical problems). She is smitten by Einstein, and you’re right, she’s not only fascinated because a man pays her attention but also because of his ideas and the fact that he facilitates her entry into the world of discussing her ideas with other men. The main problems come if one thinks this is a biography or an accurate account. I enjoyed the beginning of the novel more than the part after she marries Einstein. Somehow the two women don’t seem to match. From somebody who has overcome so many difficulties, she indeed becomes a broken woman. And of course, Einstein also seems completely different. If he was so open to her and her cooperation, was it all just a pretence? It’s possible but… This is one where each person will have to read and decide.

Something unusual, to look at the life of a very famous man, from the viewpoint of his wife and collaborator.
I wish Marie much success with her new book.
Best wishes, Pete.

Thanks, Pete. I guess it offers an interesting perspective from the more personal and private point of view. We can’t help but be curious about how the figures we only know publicly are behind closed doors, although these days it is much more difficult to keep both parts of life separate. Have a great weekend.

Comments are closed.

GET MY FREE BOOKS
%d bloggers like this:
x Logo: Shield Security
This Site Is Protected By
Shield Security